Next: Gerund Passives
Up: Gerund NP's
Previous: Determiner Gerunds
NP Gerunds
NP gerunds show a number of structural peculiarities, the crucial one being
that they have the internal properties of sentences. In the English XTAG
grammar, we adopt a position similar to that of [#!Rosenbaum67!#] and
[#!Emonds70!#] - that these gerunds are NP's exhaustively dominating a
clause. Consequently, the tree assigned to the transitive NP gerund tree
(cf. Figure 17.2) looks exactly like the declarative
transitive tree for clauses except for the root node label and the feature
values. The anchoring verb projects a VP. Auxiliary adjunction is allowed,
subject to one constraint - that the highest verb in the verbal sequence
be in gerundive form, regardless of whether it is a main or auxiliary verb.
This constraint is implemented by requiring the topmost VP node to be <mode> = ger. In the absence of any adjunction, the anchoring verb
itself is forced to be gerundive. But if the verbal sequence has more than
one verb, then the sequence and form of the verbs is limited by the
restrictions that each verb in the sequence imposes on the succeeding
verb. The nature of these restrictions for sentential clauses, and the
manner in which they are implemented in XTAG, are both discussed in
Chapter 20. The analysis and implementation discussed there
differs from that required for gerunds only in one respect - that the
highest verb in the verbal sequence is required to be <mode> = ger.
Figure:
NP Gerund tree from the transitive tree family: Gnx0Vnx1
|
|
Gnx0Vnx1 |
|
|
Additionally, the subject in the NP gerund tree is required to have <case>=acc/none/gen, i.e., it can be either a PRO (cf. example
(263)), a genitive NP (cf. example (264)), or an accusative NP
(cf. example (265)). The whole NP formed by the gerund can occur in either
nominative or accusative positions.
(262)0(262
- (263)
- ...John does not like wearing a hat.
(263)0(263
- (264)
- Are private markets approving of Washington's bashing Wall Street?
(264)0(264
- (265)
- Mother disapproved of me wearing such casual clothes.
One question that arises with respect to gerunds is whether there is anything
special about their distribution as compared to other types of NP's. In fact,
it appears that gerund NP's can occur in any NP position. Some verbs might not
seem to be very accepting of gerund NP arguments, as in ((266)) below, but we
believe this to be a semantic incompatibility rather than a syntactic problem
since the same structures are possible with other lexical items.
(265)0(265
- (266)
- ? [NPJohn's tinkeringNP] ran.
(266)0(266
- (267)
- [NPJohn's tinkeringNP] worked.
By having the root node of gerund trees be NP, the gerunds have the same
distribution as any other NP in the English XTAG grammar without doing
anything exceptional. The clause structure is captured by the form of the trees
and by inclusion in the tree families.
Next: Gerund Passives
Up: Gerund NP's
Previous: Determiner Gerunds
XTAG Project
1998-09-14