Next: Further constraints on the C
Up: Relative Clauses
Previous: Relative Clauses
The co-occurrence constraints that exist between various Comps
and the clause type of the clause they occur with are
implemented through combinations of different
clause types using the <mode> feature, the <select-mode>
feature, and the <rel-pron> feature.
Clauses are specified for the <mode> feature which indicates
the clause type of that clause. Possible values for the <mode>
feature are ind, inf, ppart, ger etc.
Comps are lexically specified for a feature named <select-mode>.
In addition, the <select-mode> feature of the Comp is
equated with the <mode> feature of its complement S by the following equation:
Sr.t:mode Comp.t:select-mode
The lexical specifications of the Comps are shown below:
- C, Comp.t:select-modeind/inf/ger/ppart
- that, Comp.t:select-modeind
- for, Comp.t:select-modeinf
The following examples display the co-occurence constraints which
the <select-mode> specifications assigned above implement.
For C:
(221)0(221
- (222)
- the book Muriel likes (S.t:<mode> = ind)
(222)0(222
- (223)
- a book to like (S.t:<mode> = inf)
(223)0(223
- (224)
- the girl reading the book (S.t:<mode> = ger)
(224)0(224
- (225)
- the book read by Muriel (S.t:<mode> = ppart)
For for:
(225)0(225
- (226)
- *the book for Muriel likes (S.t:<mode> = ind)
(226)0(226
- (227)
- a book for Mary to like (S.t:<mode> = inf)
(227)0(227
- (228)
- *the girl for reading the book (S.t:<mode> = ger)
(228)0(228
- (229)
- *the book for read by Muriel (S.t:<mode> = ppart)
For that:
(229)0(229
- (230)
- the book that Muriel likes (S.t:<mode> = ind)
(230)0(230
- (231)
- *a book that (Muriel) to like (S.t:<mode> = inf)
(231)0(231
- (232)
- *the girl that reading the book (S.t:<mode> = ger)
(232)0(232
- (233)
- *the book that read by Muriel (S.t:<mode> = ppart)
Relative clause trees that have substitution of NPw have
the following feature equations:
Sr.t:mode NPw.t:select-mode
NPw.t:select-modeind
The examples that follow are intended to provide the rationale for
the above setting of features.
(233)0(233
- (234)
- the boy whose mother chased the cat (Sr.t:modeind)
(234)0(234
- (235)
- *the boy whose mother to chase the cat (Sr.t:modeinf)
(235)0(235
- (236)
- *the boy whose mother eaten the cake (Sr.t:modeppart)
(236)0(236
- (237)
- *the boy whose mother chasing the cat (Sr.t:mode ger)
(237)0(237
- (238)
- the boy [whose mother]i Bill believes i to chase the cat
(Sr.t: modeind)
The feature equations that appear in trees which have substitution of
PPw are:
Sr.t:mode PPw.t:select-mode
PPw.t:modeind/inf 15.5
Examples that justify the above feature setting follow.
(238)0(238
- (239)
- the person [by whom] this machine was invented (Sr.t:modeind)
(239)0(239
- (240)
- a baker [in whom]i PRO to trust i (Sr.t:mode inf)
(240)0(240
- (241)
- *the fork [with which] (Geoffrey) eaten the pudding (Sr.t: modeppart)
(241)0(241
- (242)
- *the person [by whom] (this machine) inventing (Sr.t:mode ger)
Next: Further constraints on the C
Up: Relative Clauses
Previous: Relative Clauses
XTAG Project
http://www.cis.upenn.edu/~xtag